OK I got it working finally.
In advanced settings-->
Duplicate Episode Section -->
Use post title, link & publish date
Check mark --> Force Unique Names
I tried Podcast Addict and thought it fully worked out of the box but then when I tried to download a 2nd episode it would come back error 403 and fail. Then 4 hrs later those failed ones downloaded fine but Beyondpod would work until I changed the 2 advanced settings above.